Review Criteria

Review Criteria

Major changes to the scoring in 2025 with much more weighting on the score for food. This was last altered in 2009 with a change in the committee.

The original constitution, that all members must abide by, remains in place.

The table used for scoring is below:

ItemYour scoreNO half points
Startersout of 10
Mainsout of 10
Veggiesout of 10
Naanout of 5
Riceout of 5
Serviceout of 5
Hygieneout of 5
Locationout of 5
Ambienceout of 5
TOTAL

Apart from the quality, taste and value for the food, other criteria to consider is:

Food

  • Are there any different starters from the normal list?
  • Are the starters prepared in the kitchen or cooked from the freezer?
  • Is the food well presented and kept warm? Table heaters or warm plates?
  • Is there a large range of items on the menu and does anything special stand out? Does the menu clearly show how spicy a dish is? Easily readable?
  • Will the restaurant provide something that is not on the menu?

Restaurant

  • Are staff sufficiently attentive without being too keen? A sense of humour is also essential.
  • Are the facilities clean? Will the staff let you see the kitchen?
  • Would you want to bring your partner along another time?
  • Is the curry house pleasantly sited? Does it sit nicely in its surroundings? What about the proximity to pubs? Car parking?
  • Ambience covers a range of things such as lighting, decor, music. Is the dining experience enhanced by the ambience of the surroundings?